GOD… Shmod…
I’m sorry if my words and irreverence are hurtful or disdainful to you.
I don’t want my blog posts to cause anyone pain … truthful (from my perspective) but not painful.
As a child, I was taught to kneel next to my bed, hands pressed together beneath my little chin, and pray to God…
And now I lay me down to sleep…
… before climbing under the covers for the night.
For the next hour, I’d anxiously lie there, blankets pulled up over my nose, hoping that no Where The Wild Things Are monster would crawl out from under the bed or burst through the doorway and cut me into pieces and eat me.
I was an anxious child. I had my own Calvin and Hobbes world.
Sleep would eventually descend over me like a drifting parachute and I was safe from the imaginary devils inside my head for another day.
Whew! Prayer answered.
Happily, I made it through the omnipresent – artificial – dangers and survived into adulthood where the only – real – monsters that exist show up on CNN routinely.
I’ve told you before that I’m not a believer in an omnipotent deity… male, female or any other non-binary choice.
It’s not a big deal and I don’t want to write evangelically atheistic rants like Christopher Hitchens or Richard Dawkins.
I respect the desire and need for religion…the salve of poverty, war, disease, interpersonal hell… I wish it wasn’t necessary, but I understand its basis and the comfort it gives to millions.
I don’t want to judge others and their beliefs just as I don’t need or want someone hovering overhead judging me… we all have reasons for our weaknesses and faults. I judge myself pretty harshly and that’s all I can handle.
If I was a devout believer I’d probably be a better person.
I’d probably be more like Lauraine the head lady that I work with when I volunteer to chop and slice and dishwash at the Penticton soup kitchen.
Lauraine is a pious Catholic with a lively sense of humour and a Mother Teresa-like aura of warmth. She treats every person with dignity and respect and sees the inner good that so often doesn’t show on the outside of troubled people, which is everyone.
Lauraine knows I’m a non-believer but if I ever have a difficulty in any area of my life she assures me that she’ll pray for me or my loved ones. And even though I don’t believe it will have any direct impact, I feel good inside knowing that she’s sending some positive vibes.
I don’t believe in a God, but I do believe in the power of individuals to make a god-like difference for those in their circle of influence. Lauraine is real and affects my world.
Also, my inspiration doesn’t flow through the Bible, the Sutra, the Vedas, the Quran or the Torah, though each carries a wealth of wisdom.
Wisdom and understanding is cached away in a multitude of places other than religious texts. Hopefully wisdom informs beliefs.
Sometimes we come to believe in something as an accepted fact even though there’s no rational or sensible underpinning to that belief.
I was reminded of this natural human tendency when I saw a replay of perhaps my most favourite segment of television ever, of course written by one of my very favourite screenwriters, Aaron Sorkin, in the HBO series The Newsroom.
It’s a Shakespeare-style soliloquy spoken by a fictional TV news anchorman (Will McAvoy aka Jeff Daniels) during a university debate.
A young female sophomore student asks a seemingly simple question that everyone in the room takes for granted has an obvious underlying truth.
There’s a humungous lump in my throat right now.
Now you might ask where am I going with this whole ramble about prayer and I guess the answer is a simple… I’m not sure.
McAvoy’s monologue is filled with observable facts that would have us examine our belief in the “apparently obvious”. My biases align with his rant. His words are my prayer.
Powerful words delivered with eloquence.
I get it. Prayer is powerful. Prayer makes us weak and strong at the same time.
I love the sense of reverence and historic wonder I feel when I stand or sit in a church, a cathedral, a synagogue, a temple, a mosque.
I love the sound of the archaic words, thou and whence and messiah, and the swell of pipe-organ music reverberating off high arched ceilings.
So, even though I miss the halcyon days of kneeling next to my bed and talking to something or someone greater than my tiny mortal being, I can’t truly recapture those moments of prayer with the same innocence and sense of awe.
The only prayer that exists for me now is the active voice in my head that observes and confers and sifts and debates like crazy.
It’s the godless prayer of observation and wonder, confusion and fear, respect and admiration, love and desire, hope and optimism.
If I should die before I wake… well, I guess the monster under my bed finally got me.
Jul 31, 2018 @ 21:41:36
Interesting blog Larry. I always appreciate that you are not afraid to dive into any topic & as you know I’ve responded to my fair share of your blog posts over the years so I won’t shy away from dipping my big toe into the deep end of the “God pool”…. 🙂
A number of things strike me about the argument for/against the existence of God/a creator. First, one person can never force another person to either believe or disbelieve in such a deeply personal & existential question as to the existence or lack thereof of God. I admit up front that I am on the believing side of the equation but I have engaged in deep discussions with many people of other belief systems or no belief system than mine where people will forcibly through their personality tell me I am wrong & that I need to believe their way, their particular version of “truth”. When it comes to matters of such deep faith (belief) either for or against a diety it is like trying to swim upriver or trying to make another person believe one way or the other. It doesn’t work. Just like trying to convert a republican to a democrat or vice versa. Not an easy task…. 😊
Second, what might constitute a “proof” re: the existence of God for one may not be a proof to another. Proof is such a subjective thing. Example: what constitutes proof for me may not be proof to another no matter how obvious it might be to me. Here is what I consider proof & these are probably very basic but for me it has to be as such because if I acknowledge there is a Creator & I am part of His/Her creation how is it possible for that which is created to ever know the Creator? Impossible…….so from my perspective I can only go so far in my understanding before what I am conceiving becomes a product of my own imagination. Crazy eh but that is the crux of it!!!!! I can only go so far before what I am conceiving is a product of my own creation!!!!! It is like a pencil being able to describe the process of its creation or a drop of paint from the Mona Lisa being able to describe the motive force of Da Vinci in his creation of the painting. HOWEVER……saying that it doesn’t disprove to me the existence of a creator…….in my understanding everything is a reflection of the existence of a creator.
So here are my personal proof favs:
1. The fact that there is a creation presupposes the fact that there is a creator. I never studied logic in college but it seems to me that this is the basis of logic…….if there is a creation then there must be a creator. To me it is that simple & I accept it (yeah…….there is that “F” word creeping in I admit (faith) 😊
2. On a similar note……..I look around & see all of the creative genius of man in the world & it is obvious to me on all fronts that all of these inventions were just that-invented/created. It is a logical assumption. I then look at man and realize that man did not create himself so I conclude the existence of a creator greater than man. If man possesses qualities of knowledge, power, etc there must be a creative force that is all-knowledgeable, all-powerful, etc
3. The universe & all of its order and amazement seems to be too ordered and amazing to have created itself. I conclude that there is a creator of this amazing universe.
4. Here is an interesting leap of faith…….Just because I cannot see the creator doesn’t mean that a creator doesn’t exist in the same manner that I do not see electricity but yet see the evidence of it before me in many fashions or I see the evidence of magnetic force in many fashions or I see the sun a tiny ball in space 93 million miles away but appreciate its rays & other qualities manifest in the world even though I do not necessarily “see” the rays or see them influencing all life in our world……I appreciate their bounty in many other ways that make me conclude there is a sun…..etc. In the same way I am able to appreciate the existence of a creator based on so many evidences before me i.e. not the least of which Is the existence of a creation.
5. Maybe a stretch here but the existence of weakness, poverty etc makes me conclude that there is strength & richness and the ultimate expression of that i.e. the greatest perfection of that would be the qualities of a creator being all-wise, all powerful, utmost perfections etc.
6. As a believer in a creator I have concluded that a system has been in place for thousands of years where great educators have come to humanity with knowledge from & of the creator on how to live in peace & harmony. These great teachers-Abraham, Moses, Krishna, Buddha, Zoroaster, Christ, Muhammad, & as Baha’is acknowledge Baha’u’llah for this age-all have brought messages of love & peace to humanity & enlightenment on the nature of God. I conclude that the likelihood that such a system of divine teachings to humanity being purely accidental is not likely but rather there is an underlying method to this process.
7. Lastly…….I conclude that man possesses a quality that the rest of nature is deprived of……the intellect or reasoning faculty. Is it possible for man to have evolved in this milieu possessed of this quality that the rest of creation is devoid of or is this a quality that has been created in man uniquely by a creator that is omniscient etc? It seems to me that this quality must be a quality created in man for him to develop greater qualities in this world so as to recognize his divine nature. Hmmmmmm…………
Anyways……..these are my ponderings Larry & in no way are meant to sway, coerce, chastise anyone else who think differently. Believe me when I say that as Baha’i I have pondered this mystery for the better part of my life and in the end my conclusions are just that……mine & I’ll continue to stew on them for the duration. Thanks for the blog…..it got me deeply pondering once again.
Peace,
Jim
Aug 01, 2018 @ 12:23:51
Thank you so much for your amazing essay in response James. You’ve eloquently brought up a host of deep and insightful thoughts and I love your metaphorical reasoning… I have such deep respect for your opinions and thoughts, and in watching you over many years, the way you’ve lived your life. It’s a wonderful thing when people such as us can see things in a different way and yet exist with compassion and understanding of those apparently opposing beliefs. I will never tell you that you are wrong just as you show me that same respect. Thank you for taking the considerable time and thought to share this back with me and the “millions” (LOL) of the readers of this blog. I appreciate it and you tremendously…
Aug 01, 2018 @ 12:50:02
I always enjoy your blogs Sir Lawrence…..keep up the great worl pal.
🙂